Broker vs bank

Broker vs bank at mortgage renewal — the real cost

Quick answer

Your bank's renewal offer is set by their retention team. A broker shops 30–70 lenders in one application, including monolines the banks can't match. This calculator shows the gap between the two, dollar for dollar. Today's lowest advertised Canadian mortgage rate is 4.29% (5-year fixed) — refreshed weekly.

Live · Interactive Calculator

Slide, type, or tap any value below — your monthly payment and 5-year savings update instantly.

What you'll owe on renewal day
$
From your renewal letter
%
Live: lowest advertised (5-year fixed), refreshed weekly
%
5 years
25 years
Monthly payment — bank's offer
$2,859.56
Monthly payment — market rate
$2,628.01
You save $231.55/month
Your potential savings over 5 years
$13,893
$2,779 per year at today's market rate
Fairness Score
43/ 100D

Poor — your bank is charging you a significant premium.

Compounded semi-annually
Calculated using Canadian mortgage math (OSFI / IRD compliant).
Get a personalized review
Want Jay Klair to look at your actual offer?
Free, no-obligation review from a FSRA-licensed mortgage agent.

Frequently asked

How much cheaper is a broker's renewal rate vs my bank?

Broker-channel rates are typically 0.20%–0.60% below what banks quote existing customers at renewal. On $500K over 5 years, that's $3,500–$10,500 in interest savings.

Do I pay the broker at renewal?

No. On residential renewals, the broker is paid a finder's fee by the new lender. You pay the standard switch costs (appraisal, discharge, legal) — usually $300–$1,500 total.

Does using a broker hurt my credit score?

A broker typically runs one credit check that covers submissions to multiple lenders. It's the same one-hard-inquiry impact as applying directly to a single bank.